Several premises underlie Bill James’s new book, some of them radical, and it seems best to examine them individually.

1. It would be valuable to have a single number to represent the value of a player’s season. Well, sure. Wouldn’t it? People spend a lot of time rating things on a scale “from 1 to 10.” James proposes to do the same thing with baseball players, except it’s on a scale of 0 to about 50 or so (there are only about a dozen seasons in baseball history that rate higher than 50, including Barry Bonds’ 2001, which clocks in at 54). Each integer represents a third of a win, a “Win Share”. This would come in handy to resolve salary disputes, trade questions and bar arguments, for sure.

2. It is impossible to evaluate players by taking the average as a baseline. This too is true, and it has already been acknowledged by many other analysts who have introduced the concept of replacement value (the Baseball Prospectus boys with VORP, among others). James justly says that the value of a player is not in how far above the average he is but in the fact that he can play at this level at all. Poor Pete Palmer and his Linear Weights system take it on the chin for using average performance as a baseline, implying that a slightly-below average major league player has a value of less than zero.

3. The best way to analyze performance, particularly fielding, is to look at the team’s performance first, and then allocate it among the individual players. True again. For hitters it’s easy to separate individual hitting performance by ignoring situation-dependent statistics like RBI; for pitchers it’s a little more difficult; but fielders cannot be evaluated properly apart from the team.

4. The Win Shares of the players must add up to the wins of the team. Here we start to get into trouble. A team’s record can be predicted quite accurately by a Pythagorean formula, and in Win Shares James introduces a new formula, based on “marginal runs”, that is nearly as accurate. (In fact calculating Win Shares is just a matter of figuring a team’s marginal runs and allocating them among its members.) Some teams, however, significantly overperform or underperform, relative to the number of runs they score and allow. The 1984 New York Mets, who finished 90-72 despite being outscored by 24 runs, are a notorious example. It follows from James’s formulae that each marginal run a 1984 Met contributed was more valuable than each marginal run from an underperforming team, say, the 1984 Pittsburgh Pirates, who finished 75-87 despite outscoring their opponents by 48 runs. The adjustments here can range to 20% or more, dwarfing things like park factors. And it follows further that Hubie Brooks and Tony Pena both get 21 Win Shares, despite the fact that Pena outhit Brooks slightly and played a far more difficult defensive position far better. In other words, Brooks, according to James, was a better player in 1984 because his team was lucky. (All analysts agree–James himself may have been the first to say so–that when teams win a lot of close games, it’s mostly luck.) James defends such conclusions obliquely in an essay called The Snider/Mays Dilemma, as follows:

But in that case [of another overachieving team, the 1969 Mets], it seems OK, because, after all, we know what this team accomplished. We all understand that this isn’t the usual case. But in the Win Shares system, we follow the logic that whatever is accomplished by the team is credited to the players, wherever that leads us.

Now maybe we all know what the 1969 Mets accomplished, and won’t be thrown by Cleon Jones’s 30 Win Shares, but do we all know what the 1984 Pirates failed to accomplish, or will we take Tony Pena’s and Hubie Brooks’ 21 Win Shares apiece at face value? I am not certain that we should evaluate players relative to their teams’ expected instead of actual won-loss records, but I am certain that James can give a better defense of his method than he does here.

Smaller points: James says in The New Historical Baseball Abstract and elsewhere that closers are overrated and managers ought to ignore save situations and pitch their best relief pitchers when they are most valuable, i.e., in tied and one-run games. Couldn’t agree more. But in Win Shares he appears to ignore that argument, giving relievers arbitrary extra credit for saves to make his numbers work out. James also asserts that stopping the running game constitutes 50% of a catcher’s defense, although he admits that such an estimate is desperate work. This should be easy to add up, however, because we know, offensively, what stolen bases and caught stealings are worth. When I am feeling less lazy I will add up the alleged defensive contributions of some cannon-armed catcher like, say, Ivan Rodriguez, and see if they match up with what the offensive result of his SB/CS record would be worth.

(Update: Read Part 2.

Aaron Haspel | Posted June 16, 2002 @ 4:05 PM | Baseball

34 Responses to “The Bill James Version”

  1. 1 1. here

    Hey there I am so grateful I found your blog, I really found
    you by mistake, while I was searching on Bing for something else, Anyhow I am
    here now and would just like to say kudos for a remarkable post
    and a all round interesting blog (I also love the
    theme/design), I don’t have time to look over it
    all at the minute but I have book-marked it and also included your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read a lot more, Please
    do keep up the great job.

  2. 2 2. Zapatos Nike Air Max 90

    It’s appropriate time to make some plans for the long run
    and it is time to be happy. I have learn this submit and if I may I want to suggest
    you few fascinating things or suggestions. Maybe you can write subsequent articles referring to this article.
    I want to learn more issues about it!\

  3. 3 3. xbox live gold

    An outstanding share! I’ve just forwarded this onto a colleague who was conducting a little homework on this.
    And he in fact ordered me breakfast because I discovered it for
    him… lol. So allow me to reword this…. Thanks for the meal!!
    But yeah, thanks for spending time to talk about this subject here
    on your web site.

    Here is my page: xbox live gold

  4. 4 4. go to my site

    It’s amazing to pay a quick visit this website and reading the views of all friends on the topic of this paragraph, while I am also zealous of getting knowledge.

  5. 5 5. ชุดทำงาน

    Hello! I simply wish to give you a big thumbs
    up for the great info you have got right here on this
    post. I am returning to your web site for more soon.

  6. 6 6. games

    Hi just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let you know a few of the pictures
    aren’t loading properly. I’m not sure why but I think its a linking issue.
    I’ve tried it in two different browsers and both show the same outcome.

  7. 7 7. Medical Marijuana Dispensaries

    For more details about Colorado Medical Marijuana, please visit our website.

    It may be necessary to take qualified advice and experiment for yourself if you choose to progress.

    There are several versions of this type of very efficient vaporizer on the market today, including those with distinctive
    and stylish stainless steel finishes and digital temperature displays, but they tend to be pricey (around $500-700) and the forced air system does make noise similar to a blowing fan.

    Look into my blog Medical Marijuana Dispensaries

  8. 8 8. Free Xbox Live Gold Membership

    Hello, I think your site might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your blog in Firefox, it looks fine but when opening in
    Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping.
    I just wanted to give you a quick heads up!
    Other then that, very good blog!

    my website; Free Xbox Live Gold Membership

  9. 9 9. seniorenchat

    A free chat application installed on websites is also a useful way to build an online community.
    , and I remember thinking how attentive and caring he was.

    When you choose a video chat service, you’ll need to decide which features
    you’re looking for.

    Feel free to visit my weblog: seniorenchat

  10. 10 10. google

    I do not know if it’s just me or if everyone else experiencing problems with your site.

    It appears as if some of the written text within your posts are running off the
    screen. Can someone else please comment and let me know if this is
    happening to them as well? This could be a issue with my browser because I’ve had this happen previously.
    Many thanks

  11. 11 11. Libby

    Hello there I am so delighted I found your weblog, I really found you by
    mistake, while I was searching on Askjeeve for something
    else, Nonetheless I am here now and would just like to say
    thanks a lot for a tremendous post and a all
    round enjoyable blog (I also love the theme/design),
    I don’t have time to look over it all at the minute but
    I have saved it and also added your RSS feeds, so when I have
    time I will be back to read much more, Please do keep up the excellent work.

    Also visit my page … Tri Cities Appraisers (Libby)

  12. 12 12. Velma

    Hi to every , as I am genuinely keen of reading this website’s post to be updated daily.
    It consists of fastidious data.

    Here is my site: Tri Cities Real Estate Appraisal (Velma)

  13. 13 13. breast redution

    As a child, he was adorable, and he grew into a handsome young man.
    The person who is doing your procedure should haave a good deal of experience inn doing safe plastic surgery in the past.

    Plastic surgeons may not always be in favor of performing certain cosmetic procedures on teenagers
    and young adults, but there is a growing demand for cosmetic surgery among this
    age group.

  14. 14 14. ecigarettes

    These are truly wonderful ideas in regarding blogging.
    You have touched some fastidious points here.

    Any way keep up wrinting.

    my web site – ecigarettes

  15. 15 15. seo

    Hmm it appears like your site ate my first comment (it was super
    long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I had written and
    say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I too am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to
    everything. Do you have any points for newbie
    blog writers? I’d definitely appreciate it.

  16. 16 16.

    There is certainly a great deal to know about this issue.
    I really like all of the points you made.

    My page … xbox live code generator (

  17. 17 17. Ross Lynch Phone Number

    I know this website presents quality depending articles
    and other material, is there any other site which
    gives these information in quality?

  18. 18 18. South Park Stick Of Truth

    Most all of the items in the environment are interactive, and anything and anybody can
    be hit with a weapon. South Park: The Stick of Truth has an enormous amount of
    depth to it and that really comes into focus when you look at the amount of RPG and customizable elements there are in the game.
    The truth is that Carlos Menica stole the fish stick joke, is not himself funny, and lacks a few things besides.

    My blog: South Park Stick Of Truth

  19. 19 19. Heroes Of The Storm Open Beta Start

    If some one wants to be updated with newest technologies then he must be pay a visit this website and be up to date all the time.

  20. 20 20.

    One must practice the comic scripts beforehand
    at home. No matter what your field, it helps to know what you’re good at, but it also helps to recognize what
    others are good at. He hosted Comedy Central’s'The Man Show’ as well as the ubiquitous pseudo-porn for the sexually crippled, ‘Girls Gone Wild’, both solely and
    shamelessly for financial gain.

  21. 21 21. Titanfall hack

    It’s awesome for me to have a website, which is valuable in support of my experience.
    thanks admin

  22. 22 22. forex automated signals

    This has caused a big rise in the amount of positive reviews for these
    programs, and ultimately the amount of traders using them.
    If you use this fully automated software you can save a lot of time and still make money.
    Therefore if this optimised version lives up to its
    billing we expect to see big profits from this improved version.

  23. 23 23. uplifting quotes

    I visited multiple web sites but the audio feature for audio songs present at this site is truly marvelous.

  24. 24 24. lajme nga bota

    I’m curipus to find out what blog systwm you happen to be working with?
    I’m having some small security problems with my latest website and I would like to
    find something more safeguarded. Do you have any suggestions?

  25. 25 25. albert einstein sayings

    I think that is among the such a lot vital information for me.

    And i am glad studying your article. However
    wanna statement on few common things, The site taste
    is great, the articles is actually excellent : D. Good task,

  26. 26 26. Nike Air Max 1 Black

    I visited many websites but the audio feature for audio songs current at
    this web site is truly fabulous.

  27. 27 27.

    An outstanding share! I’ve just forwarded this onto
    a colleague who was conducting a little research on this.
    And he actually ordered me breakfast simply because
    I found it for him… lol. So let me reword this….
    Thank YOU for the meal!! But yeah, thanx for spending
    the time to talk about this topic here on your site.

  28. 28 28. cosmetic dentist

    Its such as you read my thoughts! You seem to
    understand a lot approximately this, such as you wrote the e-book in it or something.

    I believe that you could do with some % to power the message home a bit, but other than that, that is great
    blog. A great read. I’ll certainly be back.

  29. 29 29. easy piano lessons for beginners

    Excellent way of telling, and pleasant paragraph
    to obtain data on the topic of my presentation
    subject, which i am going to deliver in institution of
    higher education.

  30. 30 30. youth

    I like the valuable info you provide in your articles.
    I will bookmark your blog and check again here frequently.
    I’m quite sure I will learn a lot of new stuff right here!
    Best of luck for the next!

  31. 31 31.

    Hi, I do think this is an excellent website.
    I stumbledupon it ;) I’m going to come back yet again since i
    have saved as a favorite it. Money and freedom is the greatest way
    to change, may you be rich and continue to help others.

  32. 32 32. Ethel

    Awesome! Its truly remarkkable paragraph, I have got much clear
    idea on the topic of from this paragraph.

  33. 33 33. Linkin Park Guilty All The Same Lyrics

    Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact used
    to be a entertainment account it. Glance advanced to
    far brought agreeable from you! By the way, how can we keep
    in touch?

  34. 34 34. Watch women body on

    Hi my friend! I wish to say that this post is awesome, great written
    and include approximately all important infos. I’d like to
    look more posts like this .

Add a Comment

Basic HTML acceptable. Two-link limit per comment.